Next time you face a tough problem, consider waiting before asking an AI chatbot. A new study suggests that using AI later in the process—after you've done some thinking yourself—can improve your critical thinking and memory. But under tight deadlines, early AI use might help you perform better, though at a cost to independent reasoning.
The Research
Computer scientist Mina Lee of the University of Chicago and colleagues presented the study on April 14, 2026, at the CHI conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems in Barcelona. They randomly assigned 393 participants to one of eight groups. First, participants were split into two time conditions: sufficient time (30 minutes) or insufficient time (10 minutes). Then each group was further divided by when they could use OpenAI's GPT-4o chatbot: early (from the start), continuous (always available), late (available after 15 or 5 minutes), or never.
Participants played the role of a city council member who had to decide whether to accept or reject a company's proposal to fix a water contamination problem, using seven documents. They wrote an essay explaining their decision. Researchers scored essays on valid arguments, textual references, and perspective diversity.
Key findings: Among those with 30 minutes, the late-AI group scored highest on essay quality. The group with no AI at all performed best on memory recall of the documents. The late-AI group also showed the least myside bias (incorporating multiple viewpoints). In the 10-minute condition, the early-AI group scored highest on essays, but Lee warns this came at the expense of engaging deeply with the material.
Why It Matters
Barbara Oakley, a systems engineer and education expert at Oakland University, explains that the results align with two types of learning: slow, effortful reasoning and fast, automatic thinking. Participants who delayed AI use engaged in slow learning first, building a solid understanding of the problem. In real life, time pressure often forces us into fast thinking, where early AI can boost performance but may reduce our own reasoning. “You have to at least be aware of what you're signing up for,” Lee says. The study highlights a critical trade-off: speed vs. independent thought.
What You Can Do
When you have time, try to solve problems on your own first before turning to AI. This strengthens your critical thinking and memory. Under time pressure, using AI early can help, but be aware that you might rely too much on the AI's framing. Cultivate AI literacy by reflecting on when and how you use chatbots to balance efficiency with deep reasoning.
Source: Science News
Curious about your own brain? Take our free adaptive IQ test or try 306 brain training levels.
